Choosing an Aeration Blower Electric Motor for Wastewater Treatment Plants

Choosing an Aeration Blower Electric Motor for Wastewater Treatment Plants

In biological wastewater treatment plants, the blower that pushes air into the aeration basin is considered the heart of the plant. If the bacteria run out of oxygen the treatment process breaks down; that is why the blower motor runs non-stop for weeks or even months. The points to check when choosing a motor or replacing a failed one are somewhat different from those of an ordinary machine motor: load type, continuous operation, outdoor conditions and acoustic enclosure conditions are assessed together. In this article we go step by step through choosing a standard three-phase motor for Roots, rotary lobe and side channel blowers.

Foot-mounted cast iron three-phase motor standing on a plant floor
In blower drives the motor is usually foot-mounted (B3) on a common baseframe (representative image).

Motor connection by blower type

From the motor's point of view, the blowers used in treatment plants can be divided into three groups:

  • Roots (two-lobe) and rotary lobe (three-lobe) blowers: These are positive displacement machines. The motor usually stands foot-mounted on a common baseframe and drives the blower through a belt and pulleys. Some packaged units also use direct drive through a coupling. In both cases a standard IEC frame three-phase motor is a natural part of the application.
  • Side channel blowers: The motor and blower are often built as a single unit; the impeller is mounted directly on the motor shaft and the frame may be specific to the blower. With this type, the motor can be replaced by a standard model only if the existing motor is a standard IEC flange motor. For motors with a special shaft or special frame, the special motor requirement should be asked about with the nameplate and technical information.
  • Centrifugal (turbo) blowers: These run at high speed and often come with drive systems specific to their manufacturer; they are outside the scope of this article.

Load type: a blower is a constant torque machine

Roots and lobe blowers do not behave like fans. In a fan, the power drawn falls quickly as speed drops; in a positive displacement blower, as long as the back pressure stays constant, the torque on the shaft stays roughly the same. The power requirement depends mainly on two things: the blower speed (that is, the amount of air delivered) and the back pressure coming from the basin depth. When the basin water level rises or the diffusers clog, the pressure rises and so does the current drawn by the motor.

For this reason, motor power is determined from the blower manufacturer's operating point data (flow, pressure difference, required shaft power). Belt losses and the pressure increase that may later come from diffuser fouling are also taken into account. Power is not determined by looking at the machine's name; the same blower model needs different power at different basin depths.

Starting

Blowers are generally started with the blow-off valve open, that is, so that they start unloaded. If the valve is faulty or closed, the motor has to start against full pressure and the start becomes heavy. The starting method (direct, star-delta, soft starter or drive) should be stated with the order. If star-delta starting is to be used, a motor labelled 400/690 V that runs in delta on a 400 V supply is needed; HEM Motor's models of 4 kW and above have this voltage rating.

Speed: the decision for belt and coupling drives

In a belt-and-pulley drive the blower speed is set by the pulley ratio; thanks to this flexibility a 4-pole (1,500 rpm synchronous) or 2-pole (3,000 rpm synchronous) motor can be used. If you are replacing the motor in an existing system, keep the number of poles; otherwise the pulley calculation must be redone from scratch. In direct drive through a coupling, the blower speed equals the motor's rated speed and the motor choice depends directly on the blower's design speed.

In a belt arrangement the motor bearings carry the radial load caused by belt tension. The pulley should be fitted as close to the motor as possible on the shaft and belt tension kept at the blower manufacturer's value. An over-tensioned belt is one of the main reasons for shortened bearing life in a continuously running motor.

Continuous operation and environmental conditions

The blower motor runs in S1 continuous duty. A standard motor with S1 on its nameplate is designed for this job; but continuous operation has a consequence: the motor runs constantly close to rated load without any chance to cool down. That is why it is very important that the motor's own fan can draw fresh air.

  • Acoustic enclosure: Blowers often run inside an acoustic enclosure. If enclosure ventilation is inadequate, the temperature inside rises noticeably above the outside ambient. The fact that the motor is inside an enclosure and the ambient temperature inside it are stated with the order.
  • Outdoors: At outdoor blower stations the motor is exposed to rain, direct sun and dusty wind. IP55 protection guards against water jets and dust; even so, a canopy or protective roof is beneficial for motor life.
  • Humidity and condensation: In a treatment plant the air can be saturated with moisture. In standby motors, the difference between day and night temperatures can cause condensation inside the frame. If there is a standby motor that will not run for long periods, this is stated with the order; standby motors should be run briefly at regular intervals.
  • Gas and vapour: Corrosive gases may be present in the pre-treatment and sludge sections. The blower station should be in a place separate from these areas that takes in clean air.

Under these conditions the cast iron frame is often preferred for its rigidity and resistance to external effects. All our models on sale have IP55 protection and class F insulation.

Prices and technical data are on the product pages; choose a model and order online.

Speed control and dissolved oxygen

In many plants, the blower speed is adjusted with a frequency inverter according to the dissolved oxygen measurement in the basin. Our three-phase series are suitable for speed control with a frequency inverter; for prolonged operation at low speed with full torque a separately driven fan may be needed, and if the cable between the drive and the motor is long a dv/dt or sine filter is considered; these conditions are stated with the order. Because a Roots blower is a constant torque load, if long operation at low speed is planned, the minimum speed and operating time must be stated. The subject is also summarised in the question on inverter use.

Example scenario: motor replacement on a belt-driven Roots blower

The following situation is hypothetical. Suppose a municipal treatment plant has two duty Roots blowers and one standby. The nameplate of the failed motor reads 15 kW, 1,460 rpm, 400/690 V Δ/Y, 160L, IM B3, S1. The motor stands on a common baseframe inside an acoustic enclosure and is belt-connected to the blower.

  • If the power, number of poles and frame are kept, the matching model is the cast iron frame 160L-4 (15 kW, 4-pole, 1,465 rpm, IEC 160L, 27.3 A).
  • Thanks to the same frame code, the baseframe holes and pulley alignment will most likely not change; shaft and foot dimensions are confirmed with the technical drawings.
  • If the plant plans to increase the basin depth, a new operating point is requested from the blower manufacturer; if the shaft power exceeds 15 kW, the 180M-4 (18.5 kW, 1,470 rpm, IEC 180M) is considered. Since the frame moves up to 180M, the baseframe needs adapting.
  • The temperature inside the enclosure and the operating time at low speed are written on the order.

Example models for blower drives

  • 160L-4 cast iron: 15 kW (20 HP), 4-pole, 1,465 rpm, IEC 160L, 400/690 V (Δ/Y). For belt-driven medium-size Roots blowers.
  • 180M-4 cast iron: 18.5 kW (25 HP), 4-pole, 1,470 rpm, IEC 180M, 400/690 V (Δ/Y), 33.5 A.
  • 160L-2 cast iron: 18.5 kW, 2-pole, 2,940 rpm, IEC 160L, 400/690 V (Δ/Y). Only if the blower design calls for a motor in the 3,000 rpm class.

For other power ratings, see the ventilation motors page. The current price is on each model's product page.

What to send for a blower motor

  • Blower type (Roots, lobe, side channel) and the shaft power, speed and pressure difference given by the manufacturer
  • Connection: belt and pulley or coupling; mounting arrangement (B3, B35…)
  • Mains voltage and starting method; any frequency inverter and the minimum speed
  • Inside an enclosure or outdoors, ambient temperature and humidity
  • A photo of the old motor's nameplate if it is a replacement

Review suitable models and current prices on the buy electric motors page. If you are looking for a model to replace a failed motor, send the nameplate photo; for questions specific to your plant, reach us via our contact page.

HEM Motor Models Related to This Article

The cards show example models related to the topic. A suitable motor is not chosen by power alone: compare speed, voltage, mounting, shaft and connection dimensions on the product page; if unsure, send a photo of the existing motor’s nameplate on WhatsApp.

15 kW 1500 rpm Cast Iron Frame Electric Motor 160L-4

160L-4

15 kW · 1500 rpm

  • Cast iron frame · IEC 160L
  • 1465 rpm · IP55
  • Mounting: B3 foot; flange (B5/B14/B35) depending on frame — confirmed with the order

US$673.81 (€601.33)

View product
18.5 kW 1500 rpm Cast Iron Frame Electric Motor 180M-4

180M-4

18.5 kW · 1500 rpm

  • Cast iron frame · IEC 180M
  • 1470 rpm · IP55
  • Mounting: B3 foot; flange (B5/B14/B35) depending on frame — confirmed with the order

US$867.92 (€774.56)

View product
18.5 kW 3000 rpm Cast Iron Frame Electric Motor 160L-2

160L-2

18.5 kW · 3000 rpm

  • Cast iron frame · IEC 160L
  • 2940 rpm · IP55
  • Mounting: B3 foot; flange (B5/B14/B35) depending on frame — confirmed with the order

US$709.45 (€633.13)

View product

Similar Articles